The holiday season means it’s time to secure the star of your Thanksgiving table: the pie! We have some of the best local farms and bakeries in Central Mass, so forget the stress of store-bought crusts this season and place your order soon. Supporting one of our community’s dedicated pie makers is the perfect way to get a delicious, farm-fresh pie. Pro tip: Pre-order slots fill up fast (often by early November!), so we’ve rounded up the best places in Central Mass to ensure your dessert course is covered.
Here are some bakeries and farms to go to for pies in Central Mass:
Bean Counter Bakery Cafe (Worcester)
They consistently offer special Thanksgiving pre-orders featuring unique takes on holiday desserts, such as Pumpkin Brown Butter & Caramel Cake, Apple Dumplings, and various cakes and pies.
Brookfield Orchards (North Brookfield, MA)
Slices of delicious Corltand Apples make up their award-winning homemade pies! Stop by their Country Store and check out their bakery and try something new!
Crust Bakeshop (Worcester)
Crust Bakeshop (and its sister company, BirchTree Bread Company) is a highly recommended option in the city for delicious, fresh, whole pies and other baked goods, including both sweet and savory items. They often have special holiday menus.
Darby’s Bakery (West Boylston)
Mentioned frequently in local discussions as having some of the absolute best pies in Central MA for the holidays.
Fourth & Field (Stow)
This gorgeous farm-to-table restaurant in Stow has homemade baked goods, including pies, this season. Ask them about their gluten-free options!
Gerardo’s Italian Bakery (West Boylston)
They have a huge amount of delicious-looking pies for the holidays. They also have an abundance of other delicious pastries and cakes.
Nourse Farm (Westborough)
One of our contributors, Billie, highly recommended this farm for ALL of their pies. She says they are delicious!
Table Talk Pies (Worcester)
If you’re looking for an iconic, budget-friendly local option, Table Talk Pies is a Worcester staple. While known for their small snack pies, they also sell 8-inch dessert pies in classic flavors like apple, pumpkin, and sweet potato. You can usually find them at The Pie Store or in many local grocery stores.
Tougas Family Farm (Northborough)
A favorite for the holidays. They start taking pre-orders well in advance for pies, fruit crisps, and other goodies, using their own farm-grown fruit. They are a must-visit for traditional apple or berry pies.
Whittier Farms (Sutton)
A wonderful farm with an assortment of food and products, but their frozen pies look decadent, and there are too many to list here.
Did we miss your favorite farm or bakery to get pies in Central Mass? Let us know in the comments or contact us, and we will add it to the list!
